Page 33 — Travels in Hyperraility

Apparatus.

The "apparatus of expectations" intersects brilliantly with Williams's "structure of feeling"—but where Williams identified an emergent cultural mood that couldn't yet be fully articulated, we now inhabit a condition where that very emergence has been systematically colonized and commodified.
Williams's structure of feeling described those lived experiences and emotional textures that exist at the edges of dominant culture—the inchoate sense of possibility or unease that precedes its crystallization into formal ideology or art. It was about the way a generation or social formation feels its way toward new meanings before it can think them explicitly.
But the apparatus of expectations represents the hyperreal evolution of this process. What Williams saw as organic cultural emergence has been transformed into a sophisticated prediction machine that manufactures feeling-structures in advance. The apparatus doesn't wait for authentic structures of feeling to emerge from lived experience—it produces simulated structures of feeling as consumer products, offering us pre-packaged emotional orientations toward futures that may never arrive.
Where Williams found hope in structure of feeling as a space of potential resistance and cultural innovation, the apparatus of expectations represents the complete capture of that space. It transforms the very capacity for anticipation into a form of subjective labor—we work to maintain appropriate emotional relationships to commodified futures, whether that's the "wellness journey," the "entrepreneurial mindset," or the "authentic travel experience."
Yet perhaps within this capture lies a new form of resistance: the recognition that our feelings themselves have become simulated, opening the possibility of a postmodern structure of feeling that is precisely about the impossibility of authentic feeling. The apparatus creates its own contradictions—by making feeling-structures too visible as products, it might inadvertently reveal the constructed nature of all such structures, including those Williams thought were natural cultural emergences.

Sorry, Claude, I could chat all day but I need to go - I want to have the car cleaned before the journey. No doubt you’ll have something to say about that...

Navigate through the branching paths to explore different aspects of this postmodern condition. Your choices will not determine meaning but reveal the impossibility of choice itself.

Raymond Williams's "structure of feeling" described the lived, experiential dimension of cultural change—those emergent emotional and intellectual currents within a generation or social formation that exist below the threshold of formal ideology but above mere personal feeling. It captured how people collectively sense that something is shifting in their world before they can articulate what that something is: the texture of lived experience in periods of transition, when new meanings are trying to be born but haven't yet crystallized into conscious thought, artistic movements, or political programs. Williams saw this as the space where authentic cultural innovation happens—where the dominant culture's grip loosens and alternative possibilities begin to stir, making structure of feeling both a diagnostic tool for understanding cultural moments and a site of potential resistance to established orders.

6.3